Durbin Unsure Bloggers Covered By First Amendment

Dick Durbin isn’t sure Bloggers are covered by the First Amendment:

You gotta be kidding me. How repugnant.

Durbin is backing a ‘media shield law’ alongside Lindsay ‘I need to be primaried’ Graham that seemingly wants to go beyond the various state shield laws protecting reporters from divulging their sources. Key quote from Durbin Via Daily Caller:

“But here is the bottom line — the media shield law, which I am prepared to support, and I know Sen. Graham supports, still leaves an unanswered question, which I have raised many times: What is a journalist today in 2013? We know it’s someone that works for Fox or AP, but does it include a blogger? Does it include someone who is tweeting? Are these people journalists and entitled to constitutional protection? We need to ask 21st century questions about a provision that was written over 200 years ago.”

Dear Dick Durbin: It’s called the First Amendment. Everyone has the right to free speech. Yes, that includes bloggers.  Here’s a reminder:

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”

Is Durbin suggesting we need to create a media class? Our “media” is already running amok and can barely bring themselves to do their jobs. To designate a special class, protected in what they write, lends itself to even further abuse.  Suggesting that there needs to be some kind of journalist class pushes the idea that there then needs to be registration of some kind. Who would do that registration and credential giving? The obvious answer is the government and voila,  welcome to State Run Media.

Nick Gillespie makes the similar points to mine:

It’s easy to understand why he would be bothered by unwanted leaks in his administration. But his problem is the press’s gain. By definition, any media-shield law is predicated upon the government defining just who counts as a “journalist” and is thus worthy of protection—and who doesn’t count and is thus subject to prosecution. Thanks, President Obama, but we don’t need no stinking press badges, especially in an age where all sorts of decentralized reporting and unconventional news gathering come online faster than the next second-term scandal. The First Amendment is all the shield law any American needs, especially when it’s supplemented by the protections offered by the Fourth and Fifth Amendments. What we really need is a president who lives by the Constitution more than he nods to it.

EXACTLY. Read the whole thing.

As a blogger, I see things locally and nationally that others might not see.  I report on those things to those who subscribe to me or wish to listen. I am one of millions out there and that is a very good thing. We need more voices, not fewer. Giving different perspectives, opinions and information is essential for a free society. It is the need to speak out and offer a different opinion that started me blogging in the first place.  I don’t get paid for this. I do this because I believe in what I write and I have every right to be heard. I do this so my kids will have the same ability to speak out that I have. Right now, with Durbin’s statement and the mounting scandals in this administration, that fight is more real than I truly ever wanted to imagine.

Bottom Line:

No one select group of people should have an official stamp on news and information or have a soapbox all their own. That is how freedom and liberty die and dictatorships are formed.

 

Unknown's avatar

About A.P. Dillon

A.P. Dillon is a reporter currently writing at The North State Journal. She resides in the Triangle area of North Carolina. Find her on Twitter: @APDillon_ Tips: APDillon@Protonmail.com
This entry was posted in A.P. Dillon (LL1885), Government, LEGAL, Media Bias and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Durbin Unsure Bloggers Covered By First Amendment

  1. Liberty Speaks's avatar Liberty Speaks says:

    Those of you who follow Lady Liberty and myself know that there is nothing more important to us than the ability to exercise our First Amendment Right to free speech. For myself personally, I value the First Amendment greatly. I started writing to have my voice heard because I believe the actions of one individual can make a difference. To have Senator Durbin come out with a remark such as “are these people journalists and are they entitled to the Constitutional protection” is not only daft but insulting. I believe in Citizen Journalism, and will quote from one of it’s greatest supporters, Jay Rosen (NYU professor of Journalism) No relation to James Rosen of FOX, but it is ironic.
    “Think of passengers on your ship who got a boat of their own. The writing readers. The viewers who picked up a camera. The formerly atomized listeners who with modest effort can connect with each other and gain the means to speak— to the world, as it were”.
    Though I don’t agree with all of Mr. Rosen’s views, I do believe in what he has to say on the topic of the Active Audience and the Writing readers. link.http://archive.pressthink.org/2006/06/27/ppl_frmr.html
    Being a blogger is no different than being a journalist. http://archive.pressthink.org/2005/01/21/berk_essy.html It is no different than the person who writes a book. Are they only a writer if they are published? This is my contribution to the First Amendment. I am a writer, maybe not a good one, but I strive for truth no matter where it leads. Could it be the Senator is so afraid that it is not the Main stream media that people turn to for reporting any longer? Could it be that there is a section of journalism that that can not be silenced nor controlled? Please refer to some statistics on the subject http://socialmediatoday.com/anthony-baisi/1309526/blogs-vs-big-media
    Well sir, Good luck with that…Keep making statements about the First Amendment and it’s citizens use of it, it may just be a Blog that is your platform and not the Senate Floor come January 3, 2015. Sincerely, Liberty Speaks

    Like

Comments are closed.